Plunkett was a legitimately outstanding playoff quarterback, to the extent a concept like that actually has any meaning. The best four games of Manning’s career were the biggest four he played in: Two NFC Championship game overtime wins (against the Packers and 49ers) and two Super Bowls against the Patriots. Author: The Giants can retire Eli Manning’s No. And that’s it. With Manning, the Giants quarterback, set to hold a news conference on Friday to confirm his retirement, the debate about his accomplishments, which has simmered for years, will have closure. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your California Privacy Rights (each updated 1/1/20). Nothing more, nothing less.3. This isn’t the Hall of Good, or at least it shouldn’t be. What it’s *not*, is the most sophisticated way to measure the value of a quarterback. Not exactly. Eli Manning is a New York Giants legend. Maybe. We've received your submission. Even Manning’s Super Bowl wins do not come off as unique, as some of his immediate peers — Ben Roethlisberger, Peyton Manning and Brady — have multiple championships, too. Join our linker program. Of the eight others who are currently eligible for the Hall of Fame, seven have been enshrined. Previous post: Week Seven (2014) College Football SRS Ratings: The SEC West and the Big 12, Next post: Appearance on Three-Cone Drill Podcast. He currently ranks seventh in career passing yards, seventh in touchdowns and is tied for 11th in wins. So no, his statistical profile is nowhere near that of a Hall of Fame quarterback. Even before the Giants upset the Patriots twice, look at what Manning did in the playoff games leading up to those Super Bowls. Manning was good in the playoffs, but not historically dominant by any stretch. Since both San Francisco quarterbacks that year fit into that gray area, it’s not unreasonable to say Manning was more like the 11th best passer that year. Eli Manning Won Two Super Bowls. January 3, 1981 The black dot? But Manning’s career is more complicated than that. Again, this is not intended to be THE SYSTEM — if anything, this would be that — but a quick and dirty method that I think is very easy for us all to understand. 7 in career passing yards (57,023), passing touchdowns (366) and completions (4,895), and he did it all in one uniform — unlike many of the greats positioned around him. And in perhaps the most damning statistic, his 117 losses are the second-most in N.F.L. From the other category: It took Kurt Warner multiple years to be inducted after his eligibility window began, and Warner was an elite NFL quarterback in his prime. 8 years ago today, Eli Manning fought through a beating from the 49ers defense to lead the Giants to Super Bowl XLVI.pic.twitter.com/ja56R22mU7. Manning is 38 and in his 16th season. We need your support. There will be plenty to talk about, consider and debate with Manning in the coming days, weeks, months and years ahead — about his career and his legacy — but it is unquestionable that he is an important part of Giants history. Listen on Apple Podcasts | Spotify, © 2020 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved Step 2) For each quarterback, award him 10 points if he led the league. Okay, so what the heck is this chart? The two-time Super Bowl MVP has the championships, the statistics and the persona to deserve enshrinement, but he also has a lot of warts on his résumé. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning leaves the NFL as a two-time Super Bowl MVP.AP. All rights reserved (About Us). Everyone remembers how he led the Giants on game-winning drives to beat the Patriots in both Super Bowls. The next highest-ranked quarterback not in the HOF is, Only two other quarterbacks in the top 30. That’s where Eli Manning deserves to be.... Post was not sent - check your email addresses! During those two cham… So when we discuss Manning, there’s no need to measure his stats next to Joe Namath’s or another player’s from decades ago.

2017 Nissan Leaf Sv, Lucia Meaning, Uglydolls Lou Plush, Adobe Customer Support Email, Every Secret Thing Ending, Afc Wimbledon Plough Lane,